THE REF REVIEW

Shawn Smith

Referee · 134 games with data, 2018–2026

11.91accepted penalties/game
league 12.26 · about league avg
100.3penalty yards/game
league 102.3
5.75 / 6.16home / away penalties
league 5.95 / 6.30
0.23declined/game (not counted)
league 0.27; offsetting 0.01

Betting-line results

Favorite against the spread (W-L)57-72
Over-Under-Push vs closing total68-65-1

Outcomes reflect team play; shown for context only. League favorites cover roughly half the time.

Drive interruptions

134 games. Definitions on the methodology page.

MeasureThis crewLeague
Accepted offensive flags on drives with 2+ first downs, per game2.282.43
Same, per 100 drives with 2+ first downs21.723.4
% of those drives ending without points40%41%
% of crew flags in 4th quarter/OT26%26%
% of flags on the play right after a 20+ yd gain5.0%4.0%

Offensive penalties depend on the offense's play. These are descriptive counts, not judgments about any call.

Replay reviews (shown separately)

Replay reviews/challenges per game1.201.35

Mostly initiated by the replay booth or coaches, not the on-field crew.

Drive stalls after offensive flags

134 games · 630 sets of downs with an accepted offensive flag. Method

MeasureThis crewLeague
Sets of downs with an offensive flag that ended in a punt, FG try or turnover on downs51.6%
325 of 630
52.2%
of 14,803
Same, with no offensive flag (baseline)22.3%22.2%
Stalled sets of downs with an offensive flag, per game2.432.47

Offensive penalties are committed by the offense; this describes what followed the flag, not whether the call was right.

Splits

SplitGamesPen/game
Primetime3111.42
Daytime10312.06
Playoffs89.12 small sample
Regular season12612.09

Top penalty types (per game)

TypeThis refLeague
False Start2.312.22
Offensive Holding1.962.40
Defensive Pass Interference1.161.00
Unnecessary Roughness0.850.66
Defensive Holding0.670.75
Delay of Game0.490.57
Roughing the Passer0.460.38
Neutral Zone Infraction0.440.46
Defensive Offside0.420.57
Illegal Block Above the Waist0.370.36

By season

SeasonGamesPen/gameLeague
20181514.8713.03
20191613.9413.01
2020169.3110.88
20211710.6511.49
20221610.6910.88
20231711.8811.11
20241612.5012.56
20251711.5912.21
2026412.5014.85

Crew (2026, most frequent at each position)

By team

TeamGW-LPen on teamPen on opp
ARI103-76.26.8
ATL95-46.66.7
BAL117-47.35.9
BUF138-56.86.8
CAR61-56.26.8
CHI64-28.05.7
CIN51-44.46.8
CLE104-56.66.5
DAL42-22.87.0
DEN82-66.87.5
DET62-44.75.2
GB52-35.05.8
HOU75-26.13.9
IND83-54.53.9
JAX125-75.85.3
KC108-26.06.2
LA128-45.66.1
LAC94-55.34.7
LV73-45.95.7
MIA82-66.06.5
MIN64-23.37.3
NE94-54.85.2
NO53-26.24.4
NYG53-25.86.8
NYJ82-66.85.6
OAK31-28.08.0
PHI96-36.06.2
PIT106-35.46.3
SEA117-45.95.3
SF119-27.65.4
TB51-45.46.4
TEN105-56.26.6
WAS103-75.65.1

Most team samples are small; differences are usually noise.